Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gary Allen's avatar

Thanx, Nancy (& fascinating, your connection to Hangin'-judge Hathorne). I believe I saw his grave in Salem. Writing the piece felt like Six-Degrees-of-Separation.

I don't have any really repugnant ancestors (unless I go WAY back)... 'though it pains me to know that many of my (southern) kin owned slaves.

Hard to know how the words were actually pronounced in the past (or it was a self-conscious use of assonance)...

Nancy Harmon Jenkins's avatar

Sheer brilliance, Gary. I love all the connections. I too am a descendant, reluctantly, of Judge Hathorne and the Hathornes who came to Maine kept the spelling. We always thought of Nathaniel as a bit hoity-toity for changing it but I get his reasoning. Still, Maine was far enough from Salem to avoid the taint of the judge's hypocrisy. (He does remind me of an another Maine resident, albeit summer only, Chief Justice Roberts, who is even as I write being assaulted by an army of protesting kayakers swarming in the waters around his island home.)

All that being said, I have to say I adore the coincidences and I intend to use the Sam'l Johnson quote, attributing it to you, at the earliest opportunity.

Did you ever wonder about the rhyming of flood with stood in Emerson's poem?

No posts

Ready for more?